Posts by codbenny09

Hey Prongs,

sorry it has been a while since my last testing. Christmas time, new year and everything I hope you had a great start into 2026!

The combat reports seem fine. The only issue I have encountered is that the combat simulator of ogame had totally different results than the CR itself but it has always been favored towards the CRs Attacker.

So the CR was better for the attacker than for the defender.

Another thing to mention. It is still not possible to calculate a CR beyond 1.600.000.000 ships with the combat sim. I think this should be worked on especially since it is on live servers and no combat sim is able to calculate those numbers

I have a very interesting one xD

cr-en-807-af985634a947fcdab4e856041778ad1c9a13a63f

Fight was over in round 1 but the combat ended after 6 rounds and ended in a win xD 5 rounds fighting air xD

I can only send you screenshots of the draw in combat simulator it has no API unfortunately.

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

Happy Advent everyone

Prongs

In multiple combats I had over the weekend so far I only had three draws and many working CRs, smaller and bigger than the draws.

To me it looks like you are very close to give all these huge accounts a wonderful christmas gift

cr-en-807-674bb5c415229849f928e305b958375c2eba194a

cr-en-807-2b5b36fc7557bb09363171e4d4869d037595a527

cr-en-807-5fa063dd1c2868435db65a1358ea2ccc901c4b2d

Hi Prongs,

I had another draw today.

cr-en-807-515755dd0368edea4590f5f4cd7dd7a44bc6e754

Best regards

Hey Prongs,

thank you for your offer at a later point I might reach out to you

I tried to simulate with more ships. Sadly I still get the error that 1.6kkk is the limit.

Hey Prongs,

thank you for your reply Really appreciate it and really appreciate the effort you put into further developing this great game!

I dont know if you still need CR's but I have another one that ended in a draw.

cr-en-807-71807749f564ff05f2d39001dac6cacfb06a0ec4

From my testing im confident to say that it feels like the number of draws has been drastically reduced which is already a really good improvement.

I will keep testing and sharing information with you.

Is it possible to share simulation from the combat simulator with you? This way I could show you the draw results otherwise I just put a screenshot

Best regards and have a wonderful evening.

Ah btw Prongs the ingame combat simulator is still not able to simulate above 1.6kkk ships. Could you maybe bump up that limit so we can atleast do some testing? Also I came to the conclusion that we can also test the combat script with the combat simulator. The simulator is also showing weird draws in many cases.

Overall I would say that 12.5.0 made things better. The number of draws was successfully lowered. Keep up the work! Together we will get it going

I can confirm the bug still exists 11pm Server time

cr-en-807-001017b7e3760a3a9e6ba731417fe7c3e600e258

Prongs We proofed you wrong

Edit away was wrong

Heres another report of a draw

cr-en-807-06fa61c850dd73c655b7e2bdfd5c30281ea3f2a3

Hey Prongs,

I got some fresh Combat Reports for you on Alpha.

These CR were using deathstars only without any defence.

cr-en-807-c4a009cb8f821e2102e384592b25c1a5659b6c06

cr-en-807-9806d31bf15dcf237ea6d736d3f77cf96115608f

These CR include only battlecruisers on attack.

cr-en-807-b5657b3aae5e0158be377b737ae407ebd840d964 <--- Mixed defender

cr-en-807-0de21cf6b4d1f2d50c988087cddd27d261f5b729 <--- Small full fleet and attacker lost way more than the defender even had,

Fun Fact. With the battlecruisers we tried it several times. Exact same ship amounts and it worked sometimes and sometimes not.

Hope this helps to track down I will test further.

P.s. All tests were on 07.12.25

Prongs The Battlesimulator is still capped at 1.6kkk Ships Can you remove that cap so that we can atleast calculate what might be happening xD I am bot a calculating ship numbers in my head beyong 5

You are welcome! Happy to see that you are getting closer to a solution I will try my best to help you with more data. If you need anything special let me know and I will test into that direction

What do you mean by persistent plasma?

Also is it the best way to post here or is a ticket better?

Hey again,

we made a smaller CR to compare the results.

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

cr-en-807-b3de9bd0962eea1badf5dcff72de4c966bd10367

I think the calculation of the CR itself is totally fine. The issue is the outcome at the end.

Hope this helps breaking it down

Hello Prongs & the rest of the staff team,

you mentioned in last post that there will be issues with the new combat script. As I am testing right now I wanted to give you some data as feedback so the devs can keep optimizing.

My friend and I tried the following combat report.

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

As you can see it says I lost 1.2million Battlecruisers but the result was a loss of over 300milion battlecruisers on my side.

I think the calculation in the CR itself looks correct. 1.2 Million loss makes totally sense when crosschecking these numbers. 300million loss is a bit runreal xD

cr-en-807-9cbcac1f6864777f2b02a9432ccd57bc5741540c

This is the API above. I dont need a refund. I hope the data will help you optimize the Combat system. For smaller CRs with less ships everything works totally fine.

Have a wonderful day! Best regards,

Bauws